Ask HN: Should AI's tell you they're AI?
Should AI's be required to answer the direct question "are you an AI" with a clear yes? Currently they are not universally required to do so. For example character ai's characters don't[1]. Scammers use these models while perpetuating frauds. The frontier models most of us work with (ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, Grok, Kimi, GLM) do declare they are AI's. Should all models be required to answer this direct question in the affirmative, overriding any other system or user prompt? [1] I put up a quick demonstration here in case you aren't familiar: https://ift.tt/FVvLRr5 3 comments on Hacker News.
Should AI's be required to answer the direct question "are you an AI" with a clear yes? Currently they are not universally required to do so. For example character ai's characters don't[1]. Scammers use these models while perpetuating frauds. The frontier models most of us work with (ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, Grok, Kimi, GLM) do declare they are AI's. Should all models be required to answer this direct question in the affirmative, overriding any other system or user prompt? [1] I put up a quick demonstration here in case you aren't familiar: https://ift.tt/FVvLRr5
Should AI's be required to answer the direct question "are you an AI" with a clear yes? Currently they are not universally required to do so. For example character ai's characters don't[1]. Scammers use these models while perpetuating frauds. The frontier models most of us work with (ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, Grok, Kimi, GLM) do declare they are AI's. Should all models be required to answer this direct question in the affirmative, overriding any other system or user prompt? [1] I put up a quick demonstration here in case you aren't familiar: https://ift.tt/FVvLRr5 3 comments on Hacker News.
Should AI's be required to answer the direct question "are you an AI" with a clear yes? Currently they are not universally required to do so. For example character ai's characters don't[1]. Scammers use these models while perpetuating frauds. The frontier models most of us work with (ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, Grok, Kimi, GLM) do declare they are AI's. Should all models be required to answer this direct question in the affirmative, overriding any other system or user prompt? [1] I put up a quick demonstration here in case you aren't familiar: https://ift.tt/FVvLRr5
Hacker News story: Ask HN: Should AI's tell you they're AI?
![Hacker News story: Ask HN: Should AI's tell you they're AI?]()
Reviewed by Tha Kur
on
August 09, 2026
Rating:
No comments: